Article
Walk-In Shower vs. Bathtub: What to Consider Before Remodeling
| Nov 13, 2026
Modern children's bathroom featuring a white bathtub with subway tile walls, a yellow rubber duck, a blue whale bath toy, and colorful stacking toys in a recessed shelf. A navy blue vanity sits beside two hooded children's bathrobes shaped like a shark an
Article Summary
A walk-in shower can make everyday routines easier, while a bathtub offers convenience for families and anyone who enjoys soaking. Learn how both options compare in cost, accessibility, maintenance, and installation before remodeling your bathroom.
That old bathtub might be taking up valuable space, especially if nobody in your household uses it for baths. Replacing it with a walk-in shower sounds like a practical improvement, but is removing the tub really the best decision?
When comparing a walk-in shower vs. a bathtub, consider more than appearance. Both options have advantages, and the right decision depends on your household, available space, budget, and future needs. Here's what Central Texas homeowners should understand before starting a bathroom renovation.
How Much Space Do You Need for a Walk-In Shower?
A standard bathtub typically measures about 60 inches long and 30 to 32 inches wide. That means many homeowners can replace an existing tub with a walk-in shower without changing the bathroom's overall layout.
However, the available space affects what you can install. A shower with sliding glass doors may work well within the existing footprint, while a larger walk-in design with a fixed glass panel could require more room to control water splashing.
Before removing the bathtub, consider the shower entrance, door clearance, drain location, and whether you want features such as a built-in bench or recessed storage niche.
Our bathroom remodeling services can help you evaluate the existing layout and determine which shower configurations are practical.
Walk-In Shower vs. Bathtub Comparison
Here's how the two options compare for everyday use.
| Consideration | Walk-In Shower | Bathtub |
|---|---|---|
| Daily use | Convenient for quick showers | Allows bathing and soaking |
| Accessibility | Can have a lower entry threshold | Requires stepping over the tub wall |
| Space | Can provide more standing room | Combines bathing and showering in one space |
| Young children | Less convenient for bathing small children | Often easier for bathing babies and toddlers |
| Cleaning | Depends on tile, grout, and glass | Depends on tub material and enclosure |
| Installation | May require drainage and waterproofing changes | Often simpler when replacing a similar tub |
| Cost | Custom tiled showers generally cost more | Standard replacements are often less expensive |
Neither option is automatically easier to maintain or better for resale. Those considerations depend on the materials, bathroom design, and preferences of future buyers.
When Does a Walk-In Shower Make More Sense?
A walk-in shower may be a better investment in your daily comfort when:
-
You rarely take baths. A dedicated shower makes better use of the space if everyone in your household prefers showering.
-
Stepping over the tub is difficult. A low-threshold or curbless shower can make entering easier, although accessibility depends on the entire design.
-
Your existing shower feels cramped. Removing the tub may create room for a larger showering area or additional storage.
-
You want a customized shower. Depending on the available space, you can incorporate built-in niches, seating, handheld fixtures, and different tile layouts.
Keep in mind that a walk-in shower isn't automatically wheelchair-accessible. Entry dimensions, floor slope, grab bars, and seating all require thoughtful planning.
For design ideas, explore our Kitchen & Bath gallery to see how different materials and layouts can change a bathroom.
When Is Keeping a Bathtub the Better Decision?
Removing a bathtub isn't always the most practical improvement.
Families with babies or young children may find a traditional bathtub more convenient. The same applies to anyone who regularly enjoys soaking after a long day.
If your bathroom contains the home's only bathtub, think carefully before removing it. Keeping at least one tub provides more flexibility as household needs change.
Another option is to keep the bathtub in a hallway bathroom while installing a walk-in shower in the primary bathroom.
Before deciding, consider what bothers you about your current bathroom. Is the bathtub itself the problem, or would replacing worn tile, updating fixtures, and improving storage accomplish what you want?
Our article on 10 bathroom remodeling tips for Killeen homeowners covers other decisions worth making before renovation work begins.
Which Is More Expensive, a Walk-In Shower or Bathtub?
A custom tiled walk-in shower generally costs more to install than replacing an existing bathtub with a similar standard model. That's because custom showers often require additional waterproofing, tile installation, drainage work, and glass enclosures.
However, not every walk-in shower is expensive, and not every bathtub is affordable. A prefabricated shower can cost considerably less than a custom tiled installation, while a freestanding soaking tub with extensive plumbing changes can be expensive.
Several factors influence the final cost:
-
Demolition: Removing the existing tub, shower surround, and damaged materials.
-
Plumbing: Relocating drains, valves, or supply lines when necessary.
-
Waterproofing: Preparing the shower walls and floor to manage water properly.
-
Materials: Selecting tile, shower bases, tubs, fixtures, and glass enclosures.
-
Custom features: Adding benches, niches, specialty fixtures, or curbless entries.
-
Hidden repairs: Addressing deteriorated framing, subfloors, or moisture damage.
Keeping the new shower within the existing bathtub footprint may help control some costs, but plumbing and waterproofing requirements still apply.
For an accurate comparison, request a free estimate based on your actual bathroom. You can also explore our flooring and remodeling financing options if you prefer to spread eligible project expenses over time.
What Should You Know About Walk-In Shower Installation?
A beautiful shower depends on more than the tile you see when construction is finished. Several installation details affect how well it performs.
Waterproofing: Tile and grout aren't waterproofing systems. Shower walls, floors, corners, and plumbing penetrations need appropriate protection beneath the finished surfaces.
Drainage: Shower floors must slope toward the drain so water doesn't collect in unwanted areas. Curbless showers may require additional floor preparation to achieve proper drainage.
Tile selection: Not every tile is appropriate for every shower surface. Shower floor materials should provide suitable traction, while wall and floor tile must meet their intended installation requirements.
Glass and splash control: Open showers need enough room and appropriate fixture placement to help keep water within the showering area.
These details are worth discussing before construction begins. Contact our team to learn more about planning a custom shower installation.
How Do You Decide Between a Walk-In Shower and Bathtub?
Before making your final decision, ask yourself:
-
Does anyone in the household regularly take baths?
-
Is this the only bathtub in the home?
-
Would a lower shower entry make everyday use easier?
-
Is there enough space for the shower design you want?
-
Are you prepared for potential plumbing and waterproofing changes?
-
Which option will better meet your needs several years from now?
A walk-in shower often makes sense for households that primarily shower, while a bathtub or tub-shower combination offers greater bathing flexibility.
If you're building a new home rather than remodeling an existing bathroom, these decisions can be addressed earlier. Our builder consultation services can help coordinate flooring and bathroom material selections during the planning process.
Key Takeaways
-
Walk-in showers can improve everyday convenience, particularly when a lower entry threshold is helpful.
-
Bathtubs remain practical for families with young children and households that regularly take baths.
-
Custom tiled walk-in showers generally cost more than standard bathtub replacements, although materials and installation requirements affect the final price.
-
Proper waterproofing and drainage are essential for a long-lasting shower installation.
-
The best option depends on your household, available space, budget, and future needs.
Technique Flooring helps homeowners in Killeen, Temple, Harker Heights, Belton, Copperas Cove, and Salado plan bathroom renovations that fit their spaces and everyday needs.
Visit our Killeen or Temple showroom, call (254) 690-1444, or reach out to request a free estimate for your project.